A federal appeals court is weighing how to house a group of transgender inmates, all biological men currently residing in women’s prisons across the country, who are suing to prevent the Trump administration from sending them back to male-designated facilities.
The trans litigants allege under the “cruel and unusual punishment” clause of the Eighth Amendment that imprisoning them with fellow biological men would place them at a heightened risk of rape.
A three-judge panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit heard oral arguments on Friday in the case, Jane Doe v. Blanche, laying out creative alternatives to resolve the fear-of-rape claims.
In a rare move, the appellate panel, composed of two Trump appointees and one Obama-nominated judge, also granted speaking time to female inmates from a separate but related transgender prison separation lawsuit out of Texas.
The incarcerated women in that case, Fleming v. Warden T. Rule, succeeded in separating the biological men from the female prisoners housed there through the creation of a specialized unit inside Federal Medical Center-Carswell, a women’s prison in Fort Worth. Their case centered on witness testimony from female inmates reporting they have experienced sexual abuse at the hands of the biological men housed with them.
DOJ’S CREATIVE SOLUTION TO TRANSGENDER PRISON CASE WOULD MOVE MALE INMATES INTO SPECIALIZED UNIT
Judge Gregory Katsas, an appointee of President Donald Trump, noted during oral arguments that the Federal Bureau of Prisons was able to keep the biological men as well as the women safe at FMC-Carswell by placing the trans inmates in the specially-designed cell block.
“BOP has basically built within a women’s facility a jail within a jail for these gender dysphoric men, and they have managed to both protect these individuals from the risk [of rape] in the more violent male prisons and — just as important — protect the female inmates from the gender dysphoric man,” Katsas said.
Katsas drilled the Justice Department on why the federal government cannot create similar segregated living quarters at other women’s prisons. Government attorneys, however, remained adamant about moving the trans inmates to men’s facilities in accordance with Trump’s January 2025 directive to separate federal prisons by biological sex.
“You acknowledge they need a lot of protections there,” Katsas said. “You say that you will ramp up protections if things don’t work in the two facilities you’ve chosen, and that might push you, as you said, to something like you put them in the SHU.”
A special housing unit is a secure area used by BOP for de-escalation purposes that separates inmates from the general prison population, either placing them alone in solitary confinement or with a cellmate.
“You have arrangements that look like a prison within a prison in the male facility. So what’s the difference?” Katsas questioned. “What’s the constitutional difference? What do you care about whether the prison within the prison is at Carswell or in Rochester?”
Eric McArthur, an attorney in the DOJ’s civil division, had suggested transferring the trans complainants to an “extraordinarily safe” men’s prison in Rochester, Minnesota, for inmates with medical or mental health issues.
McArthur told Katsas he suspects the inmates in the Doe case will protest the idea of a miniature transgender prison, wherever the location. “You’re not going to hear from the plaintiffs that that’s a viable option,” McArthur replied. “They have filed a motion saying that even that violates [their rights].”
“I’m going to ask them about that,” Katsas said, “but I want to ask you: What’s wrong with the Fleming-Carswell arrangement from your perspective? The women are protected, and so are these plaintiffs.”
McArthur acknowledged that the FMC Carswell set-up “largely serves the government’s interest in protecting the well-being of the women,” but he argued it’s “still intruding” on BOP’s administrative authority and discretion to assign housing as it sees fit, taking into account the competing interests of all parties.
“It’s not at all clear to me that these plaintiffs, for example, are better off in a segregated unit in Carswell than in one of these extraordinarily safe men’s facilities, where they would have more freedom to move about, a wider circle of inmates with whom to socialize, and at the end of the day, if it’s necessary to protect them in the men’s facilities by putting them in a segregated unit there that’s similar to the segregated unit in the women’s facility in Carswell,” said McArthur. “I don’t see a great deal of difference between that, and I don’t think the Eighth Amendment dictates that choice and requires that they be kept in the women’s facility, segregated unit, as opposed to the men’s facility.”









