Uncategorized

Judge rejects Alex Murdaugh’s push to toss murder indictment over blood and ammo claims

A judge refused to dismiss murder charges against Alex Murdaugh, rejecting defense claims that SLED investigator David Owen misled the grand jury on blood spatter.

The judge overseeing Alex Murdaugh’s double murder retrial has refused to dismiss the charges against him, dealing another legal blow to the disgraced former attorney ahead of his April court date.

Attorneys for Murdaugh argued on Friday, Nov. 13, during a pre-trial hearing that South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) investigator David Owen gave misleading testimony regarding blood-spatter evidence and shotgun ammunition, saying it undermined the integrity of the grand jury proceedings.

In her ruling on Friday afternoon, South Carolina Circuit Court Judge Debra R. McCaslin said that while there were major errors in the state’s presentation of evidence to grand jurors, other evidence overwhelmingly supported the indictment.


“Even if the challenged testimony concerning the blood spatter on the T-shirt and shotgun ammunition were excluded from consideration by the grand jury, the remaining unchallenged evidence overwhelmingly established probable cause,” McCaslin wrote.

ALEX MURDAUGH MAKES ‘EXPLOSIVE’ BID TO BLOW UP MURDER CASE HINGING ON DNA, DIRTY MONEY AND LIES: EXPERT

While McCaslin refused to dismiss the murder indictment, she criticized the state’s lead investigator on the case.

“The Court does not take lightly Special Agent Owen’s failure to recognize and account for a laboratory report addressed directly to him prior to presenting testimony in this case,” she wrote. “Oversights of this nature undermine public confidence in the integrity of the criminal justice system.”

See also  Democratic judge under fire for releasing violent offenders calls bail law a ‘direct assault’ on rights

McCaslin also acknowledged that evidence regarding ammunition presented to the grand jury weren’t accurate, but says there’s no evidence that it was intentional.

ALEX MURDAUGH LAWYERS ALLEGE ‘FABRICATED’ EVIDENCE WAS USED TO SECURE MURDER INDICTMENTS

“Even accepting that the challenged testimony was inaccurate, the record presented does not establish intentional fabrication or prosecutorial misconduct,” she said. 

The judge said Murdaugh’s defense can challenge the disputed evidence at trial in April.

“Any inconsistencies in prior investigative statements or forensic conclusions are matters properly addressed through cross-examination and impeachment at the upcoming trial, rather than through the pretrial dismissal of facially valid indictments,” McCaslin wrote.

Murdaugh’s defense attorneys argued that Owen misled the grand jury about alleged blood-spatter evidence found on the shirt Murdaugh was wearing on June 7, 2021, when his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, were murdered at the family’s Moselle property in Colleton County.

Owen claimed that blood spatter found on Murdaugh’s shirt linked him to the killings, despite earlier testing that failed to detect human blood in samples taken from the garment.

At Murdaugh’s first murder trial, Owen said he had no intention of misleading the grand jury and stated that he did not see the final SLED lab report until after the indictment had been issued.

ALEX MURDAUGH FACES STATE PUSHBACK ON MAGGIE DNA TESTING AND PRISON LAPTOP REQUEST

See also  FBI arrests Georgia man accused of sending cryptocurrency to ISIS-linked individuals and groups

Prosecutors reiterated during the Nov. 13 hearing that the negative test results regarding the blood didn’t necessarily invalidate the blood-spatter findings, and pointed to additional testing done by the state’s expert which suggested earlier chemical treatment could have produced false negatives.

SEND US A TIP

Prosecutors said the expert continued to stand behind his conclusions and that Owen’s testimony before the grand jury accurately captured investigators’ understanding of the evidence at that point in time.

ALEX MURDAUGH DEFENSE SAYS MURDER WEAPON MAY BE TIED TO SEPARATE KILLING AS JUDGE SEEKS ANSWERS

Owen also told grand jurors that shotguns found on the Murdaugh property were loaded with the same combination of ammunition used to kill Paul, a claim the defense argues was false. Murdaugh’s attorneys maintained that none of the recovered shotguns contained the exact combination of shells found at the murder scene.

LISTEN TO THE NEW ‘CRIME & JUSTICE WITH DONNA ROTUNNO’ PODCAST

Prosecutors acknowledged that Owen’s description of the ammunition to the grand jury may have been imprecise but argued that he had not intentionally misled jurors.

GET BREAKING NEWS BY EMAIL

“This was not overtly false. This was what the agent understood at the time,” lead prosecutor Creighton Waters said.

Murdaugh was convicted of both murders in 2023, but the South Carolina Supreme Court later overturned the convictions after finding that former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill improperly influenced the jury . His retrial is scheduled to begin April 5, 2027.

See also  Deadlocked Florida election decided by coin toss
Share this article:
Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter