Sotomayor at DACA Oral Arguments: ‘This Is About Our Choice to Destroy Lives’

During oral arguments at the United States Supreme Court Tuesday on he future of the Deferred Action on Childhood Arrivals (DACA) amnesty program, Justice Sonia Sotomayor injected politics into the discussion, saying President Donald Trump has said he would find a way to keep DACA recipients in the United States but has not done so.

Sotomayor also addressed what other justices cited — the “reliance interests” of DACA recipients, or how the government program has allowed illegal migrants to get Social Security numbers, drivers licenses, and work permits that they have come to rely on.

Sotomayor said:

I think my colleagues have rightly pointed [out] there’s a whole lot of reliance interests that weren’t looked at, including the very President of — current President telling DACA-eligible people that they were safe under him and that he would find a way to keep them here. And so he hasn’t and, instead, he’s done this. And that, I think, has something to be considered before you rescind a policy.

“Right,” Solicitor General Noel Francisco said.

Newsom Commutes Sentences of California’s 548 Prisoners on Death Row

Meghan Markle’s father arrested on federal child pornography charges

Allies fear relying on US after Starshield disruption demonstrated ‘kill switch’ threat

Dems pivot from ‘affordability’ pitch to DHS probe threats after midterm wins

Russia secretly bolstered Iran’s missile arsenal before war with US, records uncover

Prosecutor overseeing Trump ‘grand conspiracy’ investigation resigns

‘I Wanted to Punch Them in the Face’: Charles Barkley Blasts Trick or Treaters, and the Full Story Makes It Almost Relatable

Lauren Boebert’s Campaign Investigating ‘Very Unusual Voting Patterns’ as She Trails in Tight Race

Progressive group’s 182-page blueprint maps out potential Dem investigations into Trump, corporate allies

‘Pro-Palestine’ Protesters Show True Colors By Targeting Jewish Businesses in Philadelphia Day Before Kristallnacht Anniversary

Former US senator and West Virginia governor Jay Rockefeller dies at 89

GOP redistricting scheme goes awry

In a new version of Stephen King’s classic, we get the ‘Carrie’ we deserve

Patrick Stewart, 1940-2026

2028 GOP battle lines emerge as Vance, Cruz, DeSantis clash over midterm losses and more top headlines

“Not just say I’ll give you six months to do it,” Sotomayer said, referring to Trump’s past announcement that he would hold off on rescinding DACA for six months to allow Congress to come up with a legislative solution.

“And where is the political decision made clearly?” Sotomayor said referring to the June 22, 2018 memorandum issued by Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen to explain why the department was rescinding DACA.

“That this is not about the law; this is about our choice to destroy lives,” Sotomayor said, directly expressing what she believed a ruling to end DACA would mean to those enrolled in it.

The back and forth between the justices, Francisco and two attorneys who argued for DACA petitioners — attorney Ted Olson and Michael Mongan, Solicitor General at California Department of Justice – included more discussion about the impact the ruling would have on both DACA recipients and the future enforcement of federal immigration law.

Olson and Mongan argued that the Trump administration did not provide a compelling reason for rescinding DACA, which came to the high court after differing results in lower court decisions on the matter.