News • Opinons • Politics

New York Times Authors Deceptively Edit Trump’s Advice to Governors on Medical Ventilators

At least eight New York Times authors shared a deceptively edited quote Monday from President Donald Trump’s recent call with state governors, creating the false impression that the president is denying federal support for ventilators that are needed in hospitals treating coronavirus patients.

In his message, the president recommended that states procure respirators and ventilators because it would be faster — but added that the federal government “will be backing you.”

The Times journalists omitted the bulk of the president’s statement as they shared the story on social media. The misleading, partial quote was also boosted by a CNN correspondent and became the lead headline at the left-wing Huffington Post.


Despite growing online backlash to this misinformation, the journalists have yet to delete or retract their comments.

The eight journalists tweeted a link to a Times article published Monday that contains President Trump’s full statement to state governors in which the president recommended that they shouldn’t wait for the federal government to fill the growing demand for respirators needed to treat people with coronavirus.


Alabama governor commutes death sentence as doubts emerge about evidence in murder conviction
University president sounds alarm as nearly half of students justify violence to stop ‘hate speech’
DHS launches nationwide ICE operation targeting illegal immigrants accused of SNAP food stamp fraud
Florida puts 77-year-old man to death for deputy’s murder as state closes in on execution record
Pennsylvania Welfare Supervisor Accused of Stealing Thousands in Food Stamps, Trading Them for Crack Cocaine
Trump Announces New Fraud Bounty Program, Nick Shirley First to Cash In
U2 Singer Bono Attacks Christians and Jews Who Support Ending Government Waste, Shuttering USAID
Husband of Democratic Party Chair Charged with Stealing $20 Million from Federal Education Grants
Honduran illegal immigrant charged with assaulting ICE officers with hammer during New Jersey traffic stop
Woke Hollywood Actor Mark Ruffalo Slams Newsom for Opposing California Billionaire Tax: ‘It’s Disqualifying’
Watch: Abdul El-Sayed Has His Hillary Clinton ‘Hot Sauce in Purse’ Moment in Cringey, Pandering Interview
Democrats Plotting to Use Bitter Ex-Girlfriend to Take Down Elon Musk
Trump Puts His Money Where His Mouth Is, Announces He’s Spending $400 Million on ‘Most Important Midterm Elections’ Ever
Judge Trump called a ‘lunatic’ abruptly backs off demand after showdown with DOJ No. 3
Trump says Ilhan Omar could go to jail or be deported, calls her ‘a disgrace to our country’

“Respirators, ventilators, all of the equipment — try getting it yourselves,” President Trump told the governors during the Monday conference call. “We will be backing you, but try getting it yourselves. Point of sales, much better, much more direct if you can get it yourself.”

But in the body of their posts, the Times journalists left out most of what the president said.

Times national correspondent Julie Bosman tweeted only the first third of the president’s statement, leaving out the part where he said the federal government will back the states.


Alabama governor commutes death sentence as doubts emerge about evidence in murder conviction
University president sounds alarm as nearly half of students justify violence to stop ‘hate speech’
DHS launches nationwide ICE operation targeting illegal immigrants accused of SNAP food stamp fraud
Florida puts 77-year-old man to death for deputy’s murder as state closes in on execution record
Pennsylvania Welfare Supervisor Accused of Stealing Thousands in Food Stamps, Trading Them for Crack Cocaine
Trump Announces New Fraud Bounty Program, Nick Shirley First to Cash In
U2 Singer Bono Attacks Christians and Jews Who Support Ending Government Waste, Shuttering USAID
Husband of Democratic Party Chair Charged with Stealing $20 Million from Federal Education Grants
Honduran illegal immigrant charged with assaulting ICE officers with hammer during New Jersey traffic stop
Woke Hollywood Actor Mark Ruffalo Slams Newsom for Opposing California Billionaire Tax: ‘It’s Disqualifying’
Watch: Abdul El-Sayed Has His Hillary Clinton ‘Hot Sauce in Purse’ Moment in Cringey, Pandering Interview
Democrats Plotting to Use Bitter Ex-Girlfriend to Take Down Elon Musk
Trump Puts His Money Where His Mouth Is, Announces He’s Spending $400 Million on ‘Most Important Midterm Elections’ Ever
Judge Trump called a ‘lunatic’ abruptly backs off demand after showdown with DOJ No. 3
Trump says Ilhan Omar could go to jail or be deported, calls her ‘a disgrace to our country’

See also  When purity politics runs its course: Even the most strident DSA politicians must learn to compromise

Bosman, reacting to intense backlash, defended herself by inaccurately claiming that “the second part of the quote repeats the first part, twice.” In fact, the second part of the president’s statement says that the federal government “will be backing you [the states].”

Mara Gay, a member of the Times editorial board, also left out most of what the president said. She also falsely accused the president of telling governors that  “they are on their own.” In actuality, the president said in his full quote that the federal government “will be backing you.”


Alabama governor commutes death sentence as doubts emerge about evidence in murder conviction
University president sounds alarm as nearly half of students justify violence to stop ‘hate speech’
DHS launches nationwide ICE operation targeting illegal immigrants accused of SNAP food stamp fraud
Florida puts 77-year-old man to death for deputy’s murder as state closes in on execution record
Pennsylvania Welfare Supervisor Accused of Stealing Thousands in Food Stamps, Trading Them for Crack Cocaine
Trump Announces New Fraud Bounty Program, Nick Shirley First to Cash In
U2 Singer Bono Attacks Christians and Jews Who Support Ending Government Waste, Shuttering USAID
Husband of Democratic Party Chair Charged with Stealing $20 Million from Federal Education Grants
Honduran illegal immigrant charged with assaulting ICE officers with hammer during New Jersey traffic stop
Woke Hollywood Actor Mark Ruffalo Slams Newsom for Opposing California Billionaire Tax: ‘It’s Disqualifying’
Watch: Abdul El-Sayed Has His Hillary Clinton ‘Hot Sauce in Purse’ Moment in Cringey, Pandering Interview
Democrats Plotting to Use Bitter Ex-Girlfriend to Take Down Elon Musk
Trump Puts His Money Where His Mouth Is, Announces He’s Spending $400 Million on ‘Most Important Midterm Elections’ Ever
Judge Trump called a ‘lunatic’ abruptly backs off demand after showdown with DOJ No. 3
Trump says Ilhan Omar could go to jail or be deported, calls her ‘a disgrace to our country’

Just ten days ago, Gay was involved in another embarrassing episode for corporate media, where she and MSNBC anchor Brian Williams horribly botched basic math to claim that billionaire Michael Bloomberg could have “given every American a million dollars.” In reality, the amount he spent amounts to less than $2 per person.

See also  When purity politics runs its course: Even the most strident DSA politicians must learn to compromise

Other Times journalists who tweeted out only the first part of the president’s quote include chief White House correspondent Peter Baker, Northwest reporter Mike Baker, arts reporter Michael Cooper, investigative reporter Sharon LaFraniere, editor Clifford Levy, and contributor Aaron E. Carroll.


Alabama governor commutes death sentence as doubts emerge about evidence in murder conviction
University president sounds alarm as nearly half of students justify violence to stop ‘hate speech’
DHS launches nationwide ICE operation targeting illegal immigrants accused of SNAP food stamp fraud
Florida puts 77-year-old man to death for deputy’s murder as state closes in on execution record
Pennsylvania Welfare Supervisor Accused of Stealing Thousands in Food Stamps, Trading Them for Crack Cocaine
Trump Announces New Fraud Bounty Program, Nick Shirley First to Cash In
U2 Singer Bono Attacks Christians and Jews Who Support Ending Government Waste, Shuttering USAID
Husband of Democratic Party Chair Charged with Stealing $20 Million from Federal Education Grants
Honduran illegal immigrant charged with assaulting ICE officers with hammer during New Jersey traffic stop
Woke Hollywood Actor Mark Ruffalo Slams Newsom for Opposing California Billionaire Tax: ‘It’s Disqualifying’
Watch: Abdul El-Sayed Has His Hillary Clinton ‘Hot Sauce in Purse’ Moment in Cringey, Pandering Interview
Democrats Plotting to Use Bitter Ex-Girlfriend to Take Down Elon Musk
Trump Puts His Money Where His Mouth Is, Announces He’s Spending $400 Million on ‘Most Important Midterm Elections’ Ever
Judge Trump called a ‘lunatic’ abruptly backs off demand after showdown with DOJ No. 3
Trump says Ilhan Omar could go to jail or be deported, calls her ‘a disgrace to our country’

The official Times twitter account also omitted the majority of the  president’s quote when it pushed out the article on Monday.

See also  When purity politics runs its course: Even the most strident DSA politicians must learn to compromise

CNN’s Oliver Darcy also shared the incomplete quote and has not addressed the dozens of fact checks in response.


Alabama governor commutes death sentence as doubts emerge about evidence in murder conviction
University president sounds alarm as nearly half of students justify violence to stop ‘hate speech’
DHS launches nationwide ICE operation targeting illegal immigrants accused of SNAP food stamp fraud
Florida puts 77-year-old man to death for deputy’s murder as state closes in on execution record
Pennsylvania Welfare Supervisor Accused of Stealing Thousands in Food Stamps, Trading Them for Crack Cocaine
Trump Announces New Fraud Bounty Program, Nick Shirley First to Cash In
U2 Singer Bono Attacks Christians and Jews Who Support Ending Government Waste, Shuttering USAID
Husband of Democratic Party Chair Charged with Stealing $20 Million from Federal Education Grants
Honduran illegal immigrant charged with assaulting ICE officers with hammer during New Jersey traffic stop
Woke Hollywood Actor Mark Ruffalo Slams Newsom for Opposing California Billionaire Tax: ‘It’s Disqualifying’
Watch: Abdul El-Sayed Has His Hillary Clinton ‘Hot Sauce in Purse’ Moment in Cringey, Pandering Interview
Democrats Plotting to Use Bitter Ex-Girlfriend to Take Down Elon Musk
Trump Puts His Money Where His Mouth Is, Announces He’s Spending $400 Million on ‘Most Important Midterm Elections’ Ever
Judge Trump called a ‘lunatic’ abruptly backs off demand after showdown with DOJ No. 3
Trump says Ilhan Omar could go to jail or be deported, calls her ‘a disgrace to our country’

All of the posts were still up at the time of this writing, despite mounting criticism about their accuracy.

Story cited here.

Share this article:
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter