A federal judge on Monday ruled in favor of House Democrats in their efforts to obtain President Donald Trump’s financial records, marking the first legal victory for Democrats as the Trump administration stonewalls their attempts at congressional oversight.
“It is not for the court to question whether the Committee’s actions are truly motivated by political considerations.” Judge Amit Mehta wrote in a ruling Monday. “Accordingly, the court will enter judgment in favor of the Oversight Committee.”
President Trump and the Trump Organization filed suit against the Democratic chairman of the House Oversight Committee, Rep. Elijah Cummings, last month, seeking relief from his subpoena request for the president’s financial records.
The court also denied their request for a stay pending appeal.
The president and his legal team decried Democrats’ efforts to obtain Trump’s financial information as an “all-out political war,” in which “subpoenas are their weapon of choice.”
New York woman convicted for throwing dynamite at boyfriend, blowing off his hand as he tried to get rid of it
Obama says motive unclear despite manifesto outlining alleged targets in WHCD shooting
White House Correspondents’ Dinner shooting: Timeline traces how suspect’s alleged cross-country plan unfolded
Wisconsin Dem’s bar laments ‘we almost got free beer day’ for Trump assassination
Full WHCD Shooter Manifesto: He Told Family He Was Willing to Kill ‘Most Everyone’ at Dinner to Get to Trump
The Reasons Why TDS Still Exists Despite Trump’s Historic Wins
Unearthed video reveals Cole Allen as quiet inventor years before alleged bid to assassinate Trump
At Least 4 Christian Farmers Gunned Down in Their Fields by Motorcycle Mounted Islamists in Nigeria
WHCD shooting suspect planned to target Trump officials, manifesto reveals
What to know about Cole Thomas Allen, the Trump dinner shooting suspect
Breaking: WHCD Gunman Manifesto, Social Accounts Found – He Targeted Trump, Was a ‘No Kings’ Rally Attendee
The Good, the Bad, And the Ugly: Inside Swamp’s New Farm Bill
WHCD Gunman Likely Targeted Trump, Trump Admin Officials: Acting AG
Security under scrutiny as WHCD attendees cite inconsistent screening before shooting
National Pizza Chain Sparks Online Fury with Reminder to Tip Their Drivers
But in his order on Monday, Judge Mehta, an Obama appointee, sided with Democrats, whom he wrote have “facially valid legislative purposes” to obtain information requested in their subpoena of Mazars USA, the president’s former accounting firm.
“It is simply not fathomable that a Constitution that grants Congress the power to remove a President for reasons including criminal behavior would deny Congress the power to investigate him for unlawful conduct — past or present — even without formally opening an impeachment inquiry,” Mehta wrote.
Cummings served a subpoena to Mazars USA in April seeking ten years of the president’s financial records in an effort to corroborate elements of Trump’s former personal attorney Michael Cohen’s testimony before the committee. Cohen claimed that Trump had defrauded insurance companies by misrepresenting the value of his assets.
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Rep. Adam Schiff, a California Democrat whose committee is also seeking information from the Trump administration, reacted to news of the decision, calling it “very important.”
New York woman convicted for throwing dynamite at boyfriend, blowing off his hand as he tried to get rid of it
Obama says motive unclear despite manifesto outlining alleged targets in WHCD shooting
White House Correspondents’ Dinner shooting: Timeline traces how suspect’s alleged cross-country plan unfolded
Wisconsin Dem’s bar laments ‘we almost got free beer day’ for Trump assassination
Full WHCD Shooter Manifesto: He Told Family He Was Willing to Kill ‘Most Everyone’ at Dinner to Get to Trump
The Reasons Why TDS Still Exists Despite Trump’s Historic Wins
Unearthed video reveals Cole Allen as quiet inventor years before alleged bid to assassinate Trump
At Least 4 Christian Farmers Gunned Down in Their Fields by Motorcycle Mounted Islamists in Nigeria
WHCD shooting suspect planned to target Trump officials, manifesto reveals
What to know about Cole Thomas Allen, the Trump dinner shooting suspect
Breaking: WHCD Gunman Manifesto, Social Accounts Found – He Targeted Trump, Was a ‘No Kings’ Rally Attendee
The Good, the Bad, And the Ugly: Inside Swamp’s New Farm Bill
WHCD Gunman Likely Targeted Trump, Trump Admin Officials: Acting AG
Security under scrutiny as WHCD attendees cite inconsistent screening before shooting
National Pizza Chain Sparks Online Fury with Reminder to Tip Their Drivers
“It shows that the courts understand the importance of oversight even if the president does not,” Schiff said.
“Mazars USA will respect the legal process and fully comply with its legal obligations. We believe strongly in the ethical and professional rules and regulations that govern our industry, our work and our client interactions. As a matter of firm policy and professional rules we do not comment on the work we conduct for our clients,” Mazars USA spokesperson Jennifer Farrington told ABC News on Monday.
Speaking to reporters as he departed the White House Monday evening, Trump said that he plans to appeal the judge’s ruling.
“Yeah, they’ll appeal it. They’ll appeal it. Sure they’ll appeal it,” Trump said.
The president “disagreed” with the ruling and slammed the judge for being appointed by Obama.
“We disagree with that ruling. It’s crazy because you look at this never happened to any other president. They’re trying to get a redo. Trying to get what we used to call in school a do-over and if you look, you know, we had no collusion, we had no obstruction. We had no nothing,” Trump said.
New York woman convicted for throwing dynamite at boyfriend, blowing off his hand as he tried to get rid of it
Obama says motive unclear despite manifesto outlining alleged targets in WHCD shooting
White House Correspondents’ Dinner shooting: Timeline traces how suspect’s alleged cross-country plan unfolded
Wisconsin Dem’s bar laments ‘we almost got free beer day’ for Trump assassination
Full WHCD Shooter Manifesto: He Told Family He Was Willing to Kill ‘Most Everyone’ at Dinner to Get to Trump
The Reasons Why TDS Still Exists Despite Trump’s Historic Wins
Unearthed video reveals Cole Allen as quiet inventor years before alleged bid to assassinate Trump
At Least 4 Christian Farmers Gunned Down in Their Fields by Motorcycle Mounted Islamists in Nigeria
WHCD shooting suspect planned to target Trump officials, manifesto reveals
What to know about Cole Thomas Allen, the Trump dinner shooting suspect
Breaking: WHCD Gunman Manifesto, Social Accounts Found – He Targeted Trump, Was a ‘No Kings’ Rally Attendee
The Good, the Bad, And the Ugly: Inside Swamp’s New Farm Bill
WHCD Gunman Likely Targeted Trump, Trump Admin Officials: Acting AG
Security under scrutiny as WHCD attendees cite inconsistent screening before shooting
National Pizza Chain Sparks Online Fury with Reminder to Tip Their Drivers
“The Democrats were very upset with the Mueller report as perhaps they should be, but, I mean the country is very happy about it because there was never anything like that. They’re trying to get a do-over or redo. You can’t do that as far as the financials are concerned it’s totally the wrong decision by obviously an Obama appointed he was a recent Obama appointed judge,” Trump added.
The House Oversight Committee was not immediately available for comment. The Trump Organization and lawyers for President Trump – both plaintiffs in the case – did not immediately respond to request for comment.
Story cited here.
