News Opinons Politics Second Amendment

FACT CHECK: Biden Says Founders Didn’t Want ‘Everyone’ to Own a Gun

CLAIM: During the Wednesday night CNN town hall Democrat presidential hopeful Joe Biden claimed the Founding Fathers did not intend for “everyone” to own guns.

VERDICT: False. The purpose of the Second Amendment was to be sure the citizens at large were armed in order to defend their lives and liberty.

Biden began his comments by suggesting that “no amendment is absolute,” adding, “None of you can stand up on the First Amendment, free speech, and yell ‘fire’ in here [or] you’ll be arrested.”


He then transitioned to Second Amendment rights, saying, “From the very beginning the Founder[s] said, ‘Not everyone is able to have a gun and you can’t have any weapon you want.’”


President says Chicagoans are ‘chanting bring in Trump’ after violent downtown riot leaves 8 shot, 1 dead
JFK’s granddaughter, Tatiana Schlossberg, reveals terminal cancer diagnosis in heartbreaking essay
Op-Ed: The Aftermath of No Kings and the Warning it Sends to Us All
Fact Check: Has the Coast Guard OK’d Swastikas, Other Hate Symbols Under Hegseth Changes?
Explosion rocks senior living apartment building in Ohio, multiple people injured
Trump Terminates Immigrant TPS Status in Minnesota to Destroy ‘Hub of… Money Laundering’ Under Governor Walz
‘Marjorie Traitor Brown’: Trump Responds to MTG’s Resignation
Israel launches attack in Gaza that Hamas says could mean ‘collapse’ of ceasefire
Chicago train fire attack shows why ‘decarceration’ policies are putting lives at risk: expert
Minneapolis police chief issues apology for linking Somali youth to local crime
Trans Activist Named Cassidy Mal Lyss (“Malice”) Arrested on 2nd Arson Charge – Previously Asked if He Could Begin Burning Churches
Reporter’s Notebook : A ‘Letter’ To Zelesnkyy Re The Peace Plan
FBI Gives Its Final Verdict on Trump Shooter Thomas Crooks
California gubernatorial hopeful Eric Swalwell embraces role as Trump’s loudest critic amid new DOJ probe
Sen. Slotkin’s home targeted with bomb threat days after she told troops to defy ‘illegal’ orders

See also  ‘Ms. Halligan was not a puppet’: DOJ says Trump’s dislike of Comey isn’t grounds to toss case

Contrary to Biden’s claims, the purpose of the Second Amendment was to be sure the citizens at large were armed in order to defend their lives and liberty. Moreover, the Founding Fathers wanted broad gun ownership in order to give teeth to the militia, should it have to be called together. This is why the phrases “well-regulated militia” and “the right to keep and bear arms” compliment each other, rather than cancel out one another, in the text of the Second Amendment.

Alexander Hamilton’s Federalist 84 is very informative here, inasmuch as Hamilton argued that natural rights are exoteric in nature, the possession of all mankind, and therefore so broadly possessed and understood that a bill of rights to protect them was unnecessary. He went so far as to warn that a bill of rights would be dangerous because it would give the government the impression that it could take action against all aspects of freedom that were not protected by explicit amendments and/or enumerations.


President says Chicagoans are ‘chanting bring in Trump’ after violent downtown riot leaves 8 shot, 1 dead
JFK’s granddaughter, Tatiana Schlossberg, reveals terminal cancer diagnosis in heartbreaking essay
Op-Ed: The Aftermath of No Kings and the Warning it Sends to Us All
Fact Check: Has the Coast Guard OK’d Swastikas, Other Hate Symbols Under Hegseth Changes?
Explosion rocks senior living apartment building in Ohio, multiple people injured
Trump Terminates Immigrant TPS Status in Minnesota to Destroy ‘Hub of… Money Laundering’ Under Governor Walz
‘Marjorie Traitor Brown’: Trump Responds to MTG’s Resignation
Israel launches attack in Gaza that Hamas says could mean ‘collapse’ of ceasefire
Chicago train fire attack shows why ‘decarceration’ policies are putting lives at risk: expert
Minneapolis police chief issues apology for linking Somali youth to local crime
Trans Activist Named Cassidy Mal Lyss (“Malice”) Arrested on 2nd Arson Charge – Previously Asked if He Could Begin Burning Churches
Reporter’s Notebook : A ‘Letter’ To Zelesnkyy Re The Peace Plan
FBI Gives Its Final Verdict on Trump Shooter Thomas Crooks
California gubernatorial hopeful Eric Swalwell embraces role as Trump’s loudest critic amid new DOJ probe
Sen. Slotkin’s home targeted with bomb threat days after she told troops to defy ‘illegal’ orders

See also  Trump allies may have been pardoned, but here’s why their legal woes aren’t over yet

Hamilton wrote, “I go further, and affirm that bills of rights, in the sense and to the extent in which they are contended for, are not only unnecessary in the proposed Constitution, but would even be dangerous. They would contain various exceptions to powers not granted; and, on this very account, would afford a colorable pretext to claim more than were granted.”

Story cited here.

Share this article:
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter