News Opinons Politics

Court Vacates Sentence for Rand Paul’s Neighbor, Says it Was Too Lenient

A federal appeals court on Monday vacated a 30-day prison sentence for a neighbor of Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) who assaulted him in 2017, ruling it was overly lenient and ordering a resentencing.

In a 16-page opinion, Judge Jane B. Stranch of the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals, writes that the lower court where Rene Boucher pleaded guilty to assaulting a member of Congress had “no compelling justification” for sentencing him far below federal guidelines.

“Federal defendants with a criminal history category of I [the lowest possible level] who were convicted of assault received an average sentence of 26 months’ imprisonment and a median sentence of 21 months,” the ruling states, citing data. “We therefore VACATE Boucher’s sentence and REMAND for resentencing.”



Thomas Paine Set America Afire with ‘Common Sense’ 250 Years Ago: Pamphlet Made Case for Revolutionary War
USDA immediately suspends all federal funding to Minnesota amid fraud investigation
‘Jeopardy!’ Host Ken Jennings Wants Trump Administration Jailed, Vows to Vote for Candidate Who Will ‘Prosecute’
Fox News Politics Newsletter: AOC accuses Vance of believing ‘American people should be assassinated’
Tim Walz Fumes About ‘Accountability’ in Shooting Death of Renee Good – He Should Start by Looking in a Mirror
New top Democrat on House CCP committee took cash from China-linked donors
DC pipe bomb defendant pleads not guilty to federal charges
Watch: Top Chicago Cop Blasts Dem, Media Narrative on Renee Good Shooting, Comes to Defense of ICE Agents Being Attacked with Cars
Fox News True Crime Newsletter: Ohio dentist murders, Kohberger sister’s warning, ‘Torso Killer’ confession
Trump pauses oil exec summit to peek at White House ballroom’s progress
Johnson meets with Muslim man who confronted, disarmed Bondi Beach attacker
Iranian officials have few options if they flee an overthrown regime
WATCH: Bodycam for Ohio dentist murders shows police went to wrong home before couple was found dead
Walz Rages That ICE Won’t Share Shooting Evidence With Sanctuary City Minneapolis – Which Outright Refuses to Cooperate With ICE
House Republicans defend ICE agent in fatal shooting, say use of force was justified
See also  Minnesota ICE shooting ignites debate over federal officer immunity

The opinion offers examples of other 30-day sentences for assaulting members of Congress and notes that the damage paled in comparison to that of Boucher, who broke five of Paul’s ribs and caused injuries that later required part of Paul’s lung to be removed.

For example, in 1981, two defendants were each sentenced to 30 days for throwing eggs at a congressman without hitting him, while a third defendant was sentenced to 15 days for spitting on a senator at an airport, writes Stranch, an Obama appointee.

“These prison terms were similar to Boucher’s, but the offense conduct  was  quite  different—as the Government argues, ‘it is difficult to understand why a tackle resulting in long-term serious injuries warrants the same sentence as an egg toss or spit in the face,’” the ruling states.


Thomas Paine Set America Afire with ‘Common Sense’ 250 Years Ago: Pamphlet Made Case for Revolutionary War
USDA immediately suspends all federal funding to Minnesota amid fraud investigation
‘Jeopardy!’ Host Ken Jennings Wants Trump Administration Jailed, Vows to Vote for Candidate Who Will ‘Prosecute’
Fox News Politics Newsletter: AOC accuses Vance of believing ‘American people should be assassinated’
Tim Walz Fumes About ‘Accountability’ in Shooting Death of Renee Good – He Should Start by Looking in a Mirror
New top Democrat on House CCP committee took cash from China-linked donors
DC pipe bomb defendant pleads not guilty to federal charges
Watch: Top Chicago Cop Blasts Dem, Media Narrative on Renee Good Shooting, Comes to Defense of ICE Agents Being Attacked with Cars
Fox News True Crime Newsletter: Ohio dentist murders, Kohberger sister’s warning, ‘Torso Killer’ confession
Trump pauses oil exec summit to peek at White House ballroom’s progress
Johnson meets with Muslim man who confronted, disarmed Bondi Beach attacker
Iranian officials have few options if they flee an overthrown regime
WATCH: Bodycam for Ohio dentist murders shows police went to wrong home before couple was found dead
Walz Rages That ICE Won’t Share Shooting Evidence With Sanctuary City Minneapolis – Which Outright Refuses to Cooperate With ICE
House Republicans defend ICE agent in fatal shooting, say use of force was justified
See also  Fox News garnered highest non-election year ratings in 2025, beating CNN and NBC

However, the ruling adds that “while that is true, those three cases occurred roughly 40 years ago, before the Sentencing  Commission  or  the  Guidelines  even  existed. Their  age  and  limited  number  make them less helpful to our analysis.”

More recent cases involving assaults on federal officers involve significantly longer sentences, such as a 2015 sentence of 24 months for a defendant who pushed a door into the arm of a government doctor and a 2014 case in which the defendant was given 21 months for bloodying a customs officer’s nose and ear.

Story cited here.

Share this article:
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter