Elizabeth Warren famously has a plan for everything—everything, that is, except financing the single-payer health care system she says she supports. It’s a telling omission that reveals what happens when Warren’s wonky tendencies come into conflict with her campaign mantras.
Since launching her presidential campaign, the Massachusetts Democrat has rolled out Warren-branded plans for everything from universal childcare to green energy to “economic patriotism.” But on health care, so far, the senator has been content to endorse Bernie Sanders’ Medicare for All plan, which would eliminate most private health insurance and set up a government-run health insurance system, without putting forth one of her own.
The Sanders plan would, according to Sanders himself as well as multiple independent estimates, require new government spending totaling somewhere between $30 and $40 trillion a year. While Sanders has outlined ways to offset some of that cost, he hasn’t put forth a plan to fully finance the additional spending. He has, however, made clear that it would require higher taxes on the middle class.
Where Democrats could use their landslide victories to redistrict
Republicans turn on Trump after devastating midterm losses hand Democrats control of Congress
WATCH: Bodycam captures chaotic response to deadly Citibank shooting in Florida
Three executions scheduled across US on same day for second time this year
Ted Cruz says ‘blue tsunami’ took over Texas after Democrats swept statewide races
Republicans, Take Note: Ballot Measure Success in Face of Blue Wave Shows Voters Still Want Conservative Policies
JD Vance Says ‘Everyone Knows Why We Lost’ in Fiery Post-Election Message
New Jersey pre-K aide faces 61 charges, accused of filming himself sexually assaulting students at school
Grocery store cyberattacks are ‘psychological warfare’ that could strike US, former FBI agent warns
See for Yourself: As El-Sayed Was Securing Win, Advisor Hasan Piker Filmed His Most Hateful Anti-American Comments Ever
Erika Kirk channels Charlie with blunt message to conservatives after GOP midterm losses
Promising Young Congressman Touted as ‘Future’ of the Republican Party After Defying Blue Wave with a Strong Win
Conservative Commentator Steve Deace Nails the Most Infuriating Part About Democrats’ Midterm Triumph: It Was Preventable
Midterm upheaval of Congress provides little reassurance for Ukraine as ‘nucleus’ of support is ousted or steps down
Latest Numbers: ‘Decoy’ Candidate Could Cost Republicans a Senate Seat as Alaska Race Comes Down to the Wire
But despite endorsing Sanders’ plan, Warren has repeatedly declined to say that middle-class taxes would have to go up. She dodged the question in earlier debates this year. And at the debate last night, she once again all but refused to answer the question directly.
Instead, she offered a vague promise that “middle-class families are going to pay less” while insisting that “those at the very top—the richest individuals and the biggest corporations—are going to pay more.”
When a debate moderator pressed her specifically on the question of taxes, she still declined to offer a direct response. Families have to deal with “total cost,” she said, reiterating her support for Medicare for All. “Costs are going to go up for wealthier individuals, and costs are going to go up for giant corporations. But for hard-working families across this country, costs are going to go down, and that’s how it should work under Medicare for All in our health care system.” The specific question—Would taxes rise for middle-class families?—remained unanswered.
In part, this is a sign that Warren, though running what is nominally a bold progressive campaign, has adopted the conventional Democratic playbook when it comes to tax hikes. As Russell Berman writes at The Atlantic, in recent years the party’s presidential candidates have tended to adhere to the rule that it’s OK to propose raising taxes on the rich—but not on the broadly defined middle class.
Where Democrats could use their landslide victories to redistrict
Republicans turn on Trump after devastating midterm losses hand Democrats control of Congress
WATCH: Bodycam captures chaotic response to deadly Citibank shooting in Florida
Three executions scheduled across US on same day for second time this year
Ted Cruz says ‘blue tsunami’ took over Texas after Democrats swept statewide races
Republicans, Take Note: Ballot Measure Success in Face of Blue Wave Shows Voters Still Want Conservative Policies
JD Vance Says ‘Everyone Knows Why We Lost’ in Fiery Post-Election Message
New Jersey pre-K aide faces 61 charges, accused of filming himself sexually assaulting students at school
Grocery store cyberattacks are ‘psychological warfare’ that could strike US, former FBI agent warns
See for Yourself: As El-Sayed Was Securing Win, Advisor Hasan Piker Filmed His Most Hateful Anti-American Comments Ever
Erika Kirk channels Charlie with blunt message to conservatives after GOP midterm losses
Promising Young Congressman Touted as ‘Future’ of the Republican Party After Defying Blue Wave with a Strong Win
Conservative Commentator Steve Deace Nails the Most Infuriating Part About Democrats’ Midterm Triumph: It Was Preventable
Midterm upheaval of Congress provides little reassurance for Ukraine as ‘nucleus’ of support is ousted or steps down
Latest Numbers: ‘Decoy’ Candidate Could Cost Republicans a Senate Seat as Alaska Race Comes Down to the Wire
But it’s also a result of the way that Warren has framed her campaign as a kind of populist uprising, one that pits the middle class against the upper crust. Warren’s entire presidential bid, and much of her career as a public figure, is predicated on the notion that her plans will come at no cost to ordinary families and that the costs of her plans will be born solely by the richest of the rich.
This is the story that Warren tells every day. It is the foundation of her presidential bid, and she is apparently unable or unwilling to deviate from it, even when the facts indicate otherwise.
There is little question that Medicare for All would require higher taxes on the middle class. But to admit that would muddle her easy populist narrative, so she goes out of her way to avoid making that admission. As is so often the case for Warren, the simple story is more important than the plain truth.
Story cited here.
